CHEDDAR SALE: Get a free 8-Year-Aged Cheddar plus FREE SHIPPING when you spend $50 or more!


Your Cart is Empty

Brothers' Favorites Gift Collection

  • Give the ultimate gift for the diehard foodie in your life. Four artisan cheeses (including our rich and decadent 8-Year-Aged Cheddar) make a perfect pairing for a classic mustard from Mustard and Co., blueberry jalapeño jam from Beloit's own Bushel and Peck, and Wisconsin-made organic crackers. For dessert, we include bite-sized caramels handmade in our home region of northern Wisconsin. These are our favorite items in our collection, and we think you'll love them too.

    *If temperatures at your location are above 60 degrees, your package will arrive in an insulated box and not in the pictured gift box. Please review our shipping policy for additional details. 


    • Three 6 oz. blocks of Wisconsin-made cheese (3 Amigos Gouda, Fratello, Smoked Gouda)

    • One 5 oz. block of Wisconsin-made 8-Year-Aged Cheddar

    • One 8 oz. jar of Classic mustard from Mustard and Co. of Seattle, WA

    • One 8 oz. jar of Blueberry Jalapeño Jam from Bushel and Peck of Beloit, WI

    • One 5 oz. package of bite-sized caramels by Sugarwood of Cumberland, WI

    • One 5 oz. package of 6-seed organic crackers from Potter's Crackers of Madison, Wisconsin

    Do you have a large order of 10 or more gift packs? Learn more about our large quantity gift package options at our Business Gifts page.


Customer Reviews
5.0 Based on 7 Reviews
Write a Review Ask a Question
  • Reviews
  • Questions

Thank you for submitting a review!

Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!

Filter Reviews:
Gloria B.
United States
Great Birthday Gift For Son-in-Law

Perfect for someone who likes spicy

Linda O.
United States United States
Cheese gift

Great experience, great product. Prompt delivery. I say to navigate website.

Ellen M.
United States United States
Nice to try.

Expensive, but delicious.

Ginette K.
United States United States
Cheese please

Awesome! Love the flavor of all the cheese I ordered

Indrani M.
United States United States
Amazing !

Loved all the cheeses. Finally found rennet free cheese. They were absolutely delicious. My fav was the sriracha. Even the crackers and cherry jam were terrific. Highly, highly recommend.