Welcome to our

Cinco de Mayo Sale

Happy Cinco de Mayo! This week only, get a free spicy cheese (or non-spicy mystery cheese) on your order. Simply add $50 of items to your cart, plus your choice of Honey Sriracha Gouda, Mango Habanero Gouda, El Diablo, 3 Amigos, or the Mystery Cheese, and that item will be automatically discounted.

Love at first bite

Shop

Shipped anywhere in the USA from Almena, Wisconsin.

Store

Refrigerate upon arrival for best quality.

Savor & Share

Unwrap and enjoy artisan Wisconsin Cheese.

Skip to results list
71 items
Column grid
Column grid

Filter

  • 3 Amigos - Spicy Gouda

    3 Amigos - Spicy Gouda

    $8.95
  • Honey Sriracha Gouda

    Honey Sriracha Gouda

    Regular price  $8.95 Sale price  $7.60
  • Mango Habanero Gouda

    Mango Habanero Gouda

    Regular price  $8.95 Sale price  $7.60
  • El Diablo - Scorpion Pepper Gouda

    El Diablo - Scorpion Pepper Gouda

    $8.95
  • Rhapsody

    Rhapsody

    Regular price  $11.95 Sale price  $10.15

    1070 reviews

  • Wisconsin Cheese Curds *Ships Fresh Daily*

    Wisconsin Cheese Curds *Ships Fresh Daily*

    $8.95
    Size
  • 8-Year-Aged Cheddar

    8-Year-Aged Cheddar

    Regular price  $12.95 Sale price  $10.95
  • Dill Havarti

    Dill Havarti

    Regular price  $8.95 Sale price  $7.60

    374 reviews

  • Fratello

    Fratello

    Regular price  $8.95 Sale price  $7.60

    294 reviews

  • "Bluegrass" Bourbon Gouda

    "Bluegrass" Bourbon Gouda

    $8.95
  • The Brotherhood Cheese Assortment Pack (8 Cheeses)

    The Brotherhood Cheese Assortment Pack (8 Cheeses)

    Regular price  $69.95 Sale price  $62.95
  • "Pretty Boy" Sharp Cheddar

    "Pretty Boy" Sharp Cheddar

    $8.95
  • Smoked Mozzarella

    Smoked Mozzarella

    $8.95
  • Smoked Gouda

    Smoked Gouda

    Regular price  $8.95 Sale price  $7.60

    271 reviews

  • Smoked Cheddar

    Smoked Cheddar

    $8.95

    335 reviews

  • Smoked Provolone

    Smoked Provolone

    $8.95

    225 reviews

  • The Charcuterie Box

    The Charcuterie Box

    Regular price  $69.95 Sale price  $62.95
  • Classic Gouda

    Classic Gouda

    $8.95

    183 reviews

  • Smoked Favorites Pack (8 Cheeses)

    Smoked Favorites Pack (8 Cheeses)

    Regular price  $69.95 Sale price  $62.95
  • Cheese & Sausage Sampler (4-Pack)

    Cheese & Sausage Sampler (4-Pack)

    Regular price  $39.95 Sale price  $35.95
  • Sharp & Flavorful Cheese Box (8 Cheeses)

    Sharp & Flavorful Cheese Box (8 Cheeses)

    Regular price  $79.95 Sale price  $71.95
  • The Ultimate Wisconsin Cheese Sampler

    The Ultimate Wisconsin Cheese Sampler

    Regular price  $124.95 Sale price  $106.20
  • 15-Year-Aged Cheddar

    15-Year-Aged Cheddar

    Regular price  $23.95 Sale price  $14.95
  • String Cheese

    String Cheese

    $7.95

    179 reviews

Mindful shipping & packing

Your cheese is in grate hands!

We take care to protect the integrity of your cheese in transit. Our vacuum-sealed, hard cheeses are safe outside of refrigeration in transit. If temperatures in your location are above 60 degrees, we ship your order in insulated boxes with gel ice packs to protect your shipment at no additional charge.

View Our Shipping Policies
Open gift box with Cheese Brothers cheese, a sausage and accompaniments on a blue background

Our Values

Cultures aren't just for making cheese

Relationships Matter

Our mission from inception has been to cultivate an approachable type of cheese company– one that utilizes farmers' markets and festivals to share our cheese and connect directly with people. Since going entirely digital, we’ve never lost sight of our commitment to building meaningful connections with our customers and community.

Personal Customer Service

We loathe robotic, impersonal customer service, so we aim to be its antithesis. Our team is here to answer any questions you have, and we love nothing more than a happy, satisfied customer! We never outsource customer service or take shortcuts when it comes to our correspondence.

Small team. Big hearts.

We value our relationships with each other just as much as our customer relationships. We consider Cheese Brothers team members as part of our family, and all opportunities with us provide a living wage.

Community Support

We pay it forward regularly by donating products and a portion of proceeds to various non-profit organizations. Complementary items in our gift boxes (jams, mustards, etc.) are always Wisconsin-made by small businesses and local artisans like us. Even down to the crackers!