Sale

Pretty Boy Sharp Wisconsin Cheddar

Get it in 2-5 business days or choose expedited shipping at checkout
  • Pretty Boy is an unabashedly sharp cheese with a propensity for the gilded and grandiose. Aged to perfection, this charming sharp cheddar is opulent with copious amounts of character as expected from a Wisconsin-made fella. Have a hunk with a cured salami and mustard, or he'll lend a steadfast hand to any dish in the kitchen!

    Net weight: 6 oz.

    Origin: Kiel, Wisconsin
    Age: 1 - 2 years
    Flavor: Nutty, tangy, rich, sharp
    Pair with: Rich cured salami, pepper jams, garlic dill mustard

FRESH TIPS:

All of our cheeses last a year or more, sealed in the fridge (they should not be frozen - exceptions below)

  • Cheese spreads last 10 months in the fridge
  • Cheese curds should be enjoyed or frozen within 2 weeks of delivery for best flavor; they can be stored in the freezer for up to 6 months
files/ezgif.com.jpg

HOW IT WORKS

1. SHOP

files/svgviewer-output.png

Shop high-quality Wisconsin cheeses, shipped nationwide from Barron, Wisconsin.

2. STORE

files/svgviewer.png

Our cheeses are vacuum-sealed, hard varieties that are safe outside of refrigeration in transit. Open the package and store your cheese in the refrigerator upon arrival for best quality.

3. ENJOY

files/svgviewer-output_1.png

Unwrap, share, and enjoy your artisan Wisconsin Cheese.

OUR CHEESES

  • High Quality
  • All Natural
  • Made in Wisconsin
  • Never Processed
  • Milk Sourced from Small Wisconsin Dairies

OUR VALUES

WE BELIEVE IN CHEESE

It guides everything we do. We believe in its power to foster good will among all, and we strive to prove it every day in our relationships with our customers, partners, team members, and community. Our mission is simple…build a new type of cheese company bonded by the brotherhood of cheese.

WE HONOR OUR ROOTS

Our cheese is made the same way since Eric’s Great Grandpa Fred came here from Switzerland in 1919 (though with a bit more fancy equipment). The milk comes in, cheese makers add the cultures, curd is formed, any seasonings are added, cheese is pressed into blocks and allowed to cure, usually for several months (or sometimes years for aged varieties). The cheese is then cut and wrapped, labeled, and shipped to your door.

WE SWEAT THE DETAILS

None of our products are ever processed or artificial in any way. Just good, old fashioned Wisconsin cheese. Milk is sourced from local family farms who care. Seasonings are always natural and simple, never artificial.

WE’RE PEOPLE, NOT ROBOTS

We hate robotic, impersonal customer service, so we aim to be its antithesis.  We are here for any question you have and we love nothing more than a happy, satisfied customer! We never outsource customer service or take shortcuts here.

Customer Reviews
4.8 Based on 298 Reviews
5 ★
92% 
273
4 ★
4% 
13
3 ★
1% 
3
2 ★
2% 
6
1 ★
1% 
3
Write a Review Ask a Question

Thank you for submitting a review!

Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!

Filter Reviews:
  • cheese
  • cheddar
  • flavor
  • taste
  • Quality
  • Cheese Brothers
  • Wisconsin
  • Rhapsody
  • texture
  • shipping
A
09/06/2024
Ann SVG verified by SHOP
United States United States

Truly the first sharp cheddar I’ve had in a long time that actually TASTES like sharp cheddar. Extra good shredded on casseroles.

MB
08/06/2024
Max B.
United States United States
I recommend this product

“Pretty Boy” Cheddar Cheese This is the best sharp cheddar cheese I have found. I make sure I am never out of this cheese!

The variety of cheeses I can get is amazing. I fully support this small Wisconsin company.

ME
08/06/2024
Mary E.
United States United States
I recommend this product

Great Sharp Cheddar Taste

We loved this with crackers, as topping for a TexMex casserole, and thin slices with fruit for a snack. Very fresh, nice and sharp.

A
07/31/2024
Annette SVG verified by SHOP
United States United States

Cheese Brothers has the most delicious variety of cheeses! It’s easy to order, singles or packages, they’re all well priced. And the cheeses are from Wisconsin too… the real thing!

K
07/24/2024
Kean SVG verified by SHOP
United States United States

I love this and all other cheeses we tried. I will only be buying cheese from cheese brothers it is well worth the price and value of the items.